Which lipstick formula is best for you?

Discovering your perfect lipstick is like finding your soulmate. Once you find one that complements you in all the right ways, there’s no turning back. With so many different types of lip formulas and finishes, looking for ‘the one’ has never been so complicated. We’re spoilt for choice, which is great in theory, until we’re looking to settle down. Then we have to decide if we prefer matte or satin, liquid or shine...
To help you find your happily ever after, here’s our guide on how to choose the best lipstick formula for you.
RELATED: The best ‘my lips but better’ lipsticks
Liquid
Liquid lipstick is the cool, new kid on the block. It comes in every colour under the sun and just about every price range. If you want a statement lip in a long-lasting formula, liquid lipstick is your guy. Trust me, once you’ve applied it, it’s going nowhere. It’s also highly pigmented so always use a light hand to apply. Alphie Sadsad, Pro Artist for Bobbi Brown Cosmetics says, “Liquid lipstick often has great colour intensity and staying power, but most formulas are matte and can feel drying.” So if you’re particularly prone to dryness, I’d look elsewhere.
bh loves: ModelCo LIQUID LIPSTICK, Lush Liquid Lipstick, Nutrimetics nc Vivid Liquid Lipstick, MODELROCK Cosmetics Liquid Last: Liquid to Matte Lipstick
Matte
Matte lipstick is iconic. There’s something so glamourous about swiping a matte lippie in a bold shade across your lips before heading out the door. If you’re looking to add a sophisticated finish to your makeup, a matte lip is the way to go. As with liquid lipsticks, matte formulas can be drying. If you have dry lips but still want to wear a matte, prepare accordingly. “Make sure your lips are ready by pampering them with lip balm and then using a toothbrush or washcloth to gently exfoliate any dry skin before you apply your lipstick,” explains Alphie. When you’re ready to apply your lipstick, prep lips with a collagen-boosting lip balm, fill your lips in with a liner in your desired shade and top with a matte lipstick.
bh loves: ulta3 Matte Lipstick, Bobbi Brown Creamy Matte Lip Color, Chi Chi Viva La Diva Lipsticks, L'Oréal Paris Colour Riche Moisture Matte Lipstick
Satin
“[A] satin finish is somewhere between a matte and a cream,” describes Alphie. “It’s not as glossy as a cream finish, but not as flat as a matte finish.” Satin lipsticks still give you a decent colour payoff, without being as drying as a matte or liquid formula. The finish is slightly glossy and will give lips a soft, smooth appearance. Although a satin formula isn’t long-wearing, it’s very flattering on the lips and almost foolproof to apply. If you have thin lips, you’ll find that a satin formula gives you the polished finish of a lipstick without drawing attention to the size of your lips. “To make lips appear fuller, dab a little gloss on the Cupid’s bow for a rich pout,” suggests Alphie.
bh loves: Clinique High Impact™ Lip Colour SPF 15, Innoxa Satin Sheen Lipstick, Estée Lauder Pure Colour Long Lasting Lipstick, NYX Butter Lipstick
Stain
A stain is great for anyone looking for a touch of colour that stays put all day. A stain isn’t as pigmented as a liquid lipstick, so you can achieve a more natural result. That being said, they are very buildable so you can simply apply more on top if you’re after more colour. If you have dry lips and want a long-lasting colour, a stain is better than a matte or liquid lipstick. Unlike other lip formulas, stains can be applied over a lip balm or gloss and will still leave your lips with a sheer tint. Although some stains contain alcohol which can be drying, you can always apply lip balm on top to hydrate your lips throughout the day. Stains are also highly versatile and “often multitask as a lip and cheek product,” adds Alphie.
bh loves: e.l.f. cosmetics Essential Lip Stain, The Body Shop Lip and Cheek Stain, Revlon ColorBurst™ Balm Stain, Yves Saint Laurent Rouge Pur Couture Pure Color Lipstick
Shine
A lipstick with a shine finish is like lip gloss for grown-ups. It’s low maintenance, low commitment and moisturising, making it perfect for beginners. The formulas often come in shades that are similar to your natural lip colour, so they’re a great everyday choice. These lipsticks are light-reflecting, making them amazing at creating the illusion of a fuller pout. “[Try] following your natural lip line with a lip pencil in the same shade, or a shade lighter than your lipstick,” suggests Alphie. Fill in your lips with a shine lipstick formula for luscious lips with a subtle sheen.
bh loves: Rimmel London Moisture Renew Sheer & Shine Lipstick, M.A.C Mineralize Rich Lipstick, Bobbi Brown Sheer Lip Color, essence sheer & shine lipstick
RELATED: 10 of the best matte lipsticks by shade
What’s your favorite lipstick? Were you using the right lip formula for you?
Have you tried any of the products mentioned above?
Review them now to earn points that you can swap for free beauty products in RewardsRoom.
155 Member Comments
Satin is where its at!
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
Matte lipsticks are my favourite. They look good with anything.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I really think the satin is the best choice overall for me.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
Huge fan of liquid and matte lipsticks and trying to get into the satin/stain lippies.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
Over the last one year i have become a fan of satin lipstick. Liquid and matte lipstick are too drying for me.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
My favourties are liquid lipsticks but I seem to be able to wear any formula.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I like and use all types. But at the moment I am favouring the liquid lipsticks.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
Mattes are definitely my huge fave right now.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I'm not a big lipstick wearer and will favour a tinted lipgloss over lippy! If I do wear lippy I like a nude semi matte!
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I’ve been loving Too Faced matte liquid lipstick and the new Bobbi Brown crushed lipstick, bit are amazing and not drying at all.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
Satin lipsticks are my pick - not too slippery, not too dry!
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I am a fan of the Ulta 3 Matte lipsticks for a long time. Affordable and good quality.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I didn't know Ulta3 made mattes! Thankyou Moonlight : )
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I’ve been playing around with different types of lipsticks after being a lip gloss gal for the longest time. I must admit I think mattes are over-rated. The colour just looks so flat on me. I much prefer a satin over a matte. Even liquid lipsticks like Stila are not so drying even though it dries down matte,
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
Why oh why is the Bobbi Brown Lip Crush not listed?! It's such a great lippie and it's only just come out! I tend to go with what I'm in the mood for, but if I'm going hard, it's always bold.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I loved the Urban Decay Glitter lipstick you had on , during the glosscars marketplace. You rocked in it.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I like matte lipstick
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I have no issue with choosing the type of lipstick but getting a colour I love is a different matter. Still getting over Estee Lauder discontinuing not only colours but actual lipstick formulations ages ago.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
If the colour doesn't work for me, I mix it with other colours till I get the right shade. No lipstick/makeup goes to waste in my hizzle.
Formulas are a little harder to work with though. If its crumbly or non lasting, theres not much you can do. Blah!
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
Recently, I've been loving the satin look. It's just right in the middle of glossy and matte. It gives a great look on my lips!
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
i use all and all colours, i dont discriminate hahahah
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I love satins! Perfect amount of colour and moisture!
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
I am using lipstick that gives a satin finish at the moment. I hate my lips feeling dry.
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
Lipgloss all the way or the occasional liquid lipstick when I want to lock a bold colour in place :)
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0
Ive been loving matte at the moment but think i might try satin!
- Log in or register to commentReply to comment
- Likes 0